Trade question....

[Jumpman23]

I have 3 QB's and I'm trying to trade one but not sure which one to get rid of and what I should ask for in return. I have Warner, McNabb, Rodgers.

Which one do you think I should trade and what do you think I could ask for in return? I'm probaly hoping to get a decent WR in return. Maybe I could package another player in with a QB and get someone decent in return.

Right now I have...(RB) Lynch, Gore, DeAngelo Williams, Chris Johnson

(WR) Holt, Royal, Marshall, Lance Moore, DeSean Jackson.


What do you guys think?

 

[Addict101]

I'd consider packaging McNabb and Holt for a better WR. McNabb always starts hot but then cools down, and Holt is just in a bad situation in St. Louis. I think you should be able to get really good wideout packaging those two. Maybe an Andre Johnson?

 

[Jumpman23]

Maybe an Andre Johnson?

I was kind of thinking the same thing. What about Reggie Wayne?

You think if I package McNabb and Holt together I can get a top #1 WR?

 

[OTK]

I would personally package McNabb and Jackson. It might have more appeal to the buyer to get the QB/WR combo that has looked good so far. I personally think McNabb is your worst QB and Jackson might decline. I think Jackson could have a big, big year, but I think there's a good chance you'd be selling at his peak, which is the main goal when trading.

I don't know about getting someone like Wayne (although it'd be amazing if you could), but I'm sure you could get a very good WR for those two. Marshall is a top 5 WR, so if you can get another top 10, top 15 to go along with him, Gore, Lynch, Rodgers and Warner and you have yourself a pretty damn good team, depending on the league.

 

[Addict101]

I was kind of thinking the same thing. What about Reggie Wayne?

You think if I package McNabb and Holt together I can get a top #1 WR?

If a team has a weak QB I would think you could get a #1 WR for McNabb/Holt.

 

[JakeT.]

You should definitely get a #1 WR for McNabb/Holt. I'd move Warner/Holt personally for a #1. Try Randy Moss for Kurt Warner.

 

[Jumpman23]

Thanks for the help guys...I offered McNabb and Jackson for Wayne so we'll see what happens.

One more trade question in a different league, if you dont mind.

Who do you think I could ask for (WR/RB) in return for Derek Anderson and Braylon Edwards?

Right now I have (QB) Warner, Orton, Anderson....(RB) Westbrook, Slaton, McFadden, Chris Johnson, Edge.... (WR) DeSean Jackson, Marshall, Cotchery, Chambers, Edwards.... (TE) Winslow

 

[JakeT.]

Would rather see you offer up Anderson and McFadden for someone like Addai just to see if you get lucky.

 

[hoss]

what about this trade

R Moss for R Brown

thanks

 

[JakeT.]

what about this trade

R Moss for R Brown

thanks

Tough call there. I have those guys ranked about even with maybe a tiny edge to Moss. Really depends on your needs at WR and RB...

 

[hoss]

(WR) L Firtzgerald L Moore B Engram


(RB) L Maronay W Parker LenDale White P Thomas

 

[JakeT.]

And do you have Brown or Moss?

 

[hoss]

Moss

 

[JakeT.]

Hmm interesting trade but I think I'd hang tight. You have 3 decent RBs you can play matchups with and Moore/Engram are not going to be reliable at WR. Ronnie Brown will have bad weeks as well and the last 2 are not indicative of what I'd expect the rest of the season. Maroney should be very good once healthy. Parker is dinged but I'd keep what I had personally.

 

[hoss]

thanks for the help

 

[Jumpman23]

Jake,

The trade I offered McNabb and Jackson for Wayne was declined. Honestly I have no reason why he would of declined it because it would of really helped his team too, but whatever.

You think Jennings would be a good WR to go after and would he be worth it for McNabb and Jackson?

Who are a couple of other WR's you would try to get?

 

[raiseany]

For the love of god take Brown before the other guy gets a brain. Brown will outscore moss 3 to 1.

 

[FairWarning]

what about this trade

R Moss for R Brown

thanks

NE doesn't throw deep anymore. I would make that trade.

 

[FairWarning]

Jake,

The trade I offered McNabb and Jackson for Wayne was declined. Honestly I have no reason why he would of declined it because it would of really helped his team too, but whatever.

You think Jennings would be a good WR to go after and would he be worth it for McNabb and Jackson?

Who are a couple of other WR's you would try to get?

Jennings would be great to go after. Check the WW for Donnie Avery too.

 

[JakeT.]

Jake,

The trade I offered McNabb and Jackson for Wayne was declined. Honestly I have no reason why he would of declined it because it would of really helped his team too, but whatever.

You think Jennings would be a good WR to go after and would he be worth it for McNabb and Jackson?

Who are a couple of other WR's you would try to get?

Not a fan of that trade. Jennings isn't as great of a fantasy option without Favre. Just not enough back IMO.